Respectfully, I Must Disagree

Many of you probably saw Dr. Oz yesterday. I usually try to watch his show because I always learn something. However, I don't always agree with what I see or what his guests may have to say. Yesterday was one of those times. His show was about cosmetics and how dangerous some of them are for us. While I agreed with most of what he was saying, he had a guest, Paula Begoun, who said that fragrances were harmful. Paula made a comment that fragrances were harmful to our health and it didn't matter if they were artificial or natural fragrances. 

I'm not sure what she meant by "natural" but she used the example of lavender. She claimed that lavender was harmful to our skin.  I don't know what kind of lavender she was talking about, but I feel like I need to make a clarification here. She said lavender causes cell death. If she was talking about lavender essential oils, she couldn't be farther from the truth. In fact, lavender does not cause cell death, time causes cell death, along with chemicals and other environmental/health factors. But lavender essential oil does not cause cell death. She mentioned a few other fragrances such as cinnamon, eucalyptus, peppermint and menthol, claiming they cause irritation, break down collagen, impair our immune defense and cause inflammation. While I agree that some of the stronger oils can cause irritation and inflammation, I have never seen any studies or literature from the top essential oil experts that claim these oils impair our immune system or break down collagen. In fact, quite the opposite is true. 

If she was talking about synthetic fragrances, I concur with what she is saying. Because of our current labeling laws, a synthetic fragrance can be called "natural". For example, if some company fragrances their lotion with synthetic lilac, it can still be called a natural lilac fragrance because lilacs are a natural fragrance. That doesn't necessarily mean lilac essential oil was used to fragrance the product (most likely it wasn't), it only means it smells like something natural. Again, I'm not sure what she meant by "natural". 

While Ms. Begoun is an expert on cosmetics and the cosmetic industry, she clearly is not an expert on essential oils. Essential oils have been around almost as long as man. The Egyptians and Chinese have been using essential oils for thousands of years. Well preserved alabaster jars of essential oils have been found in King Tut's tomb. There are 188 references to essential oils in the Bible. So I think we can rest assured that essential oils have their place.  

Lavender oil has, among other uses, been listed specifically for its benefit to the skin. Not only does it not cause cell death, but it actually regenerates cells. Specifically it is listed as useful for acne, burns (cell renewal) dandruff, diaper rash, scarring (minimizes), stretch marks, boils, bruises, cold sores, hives, insect bites and bee stings, infections of the skin, abscesses, skin conditions such as eczema and psoriasis and sunburns, to mention  few.

While I would never put cinnamon oil directly on my skin it too is a valuable oil. It is one of the most ancient of oils and was used in just about every prescription in ancient China. It is generally regarded as safe (GRAS) for internal consumption by the FDA. However, cinnamon oil should always be well diluted because it is a very strong oil. A little common sense would be in order here. Repeated use can cause contact sensitization, it should be avoided during pregnancy and can cause skin irritation. I have a friend who is allergic to cinnamon oil, so she never buys any of my soaps with cinnamon in it. It is very useful in killing germs as it is anti-bacterial, anti-fungal, anti-infectious, antimicrobial, antiseptic, anti-viral and a purifier.

Eucalyptus is another very useful oil also containing anti-bacterial, anti-infectious, anti-viral and antiseptic properties. In regards to skin it is wonderful for acne, skin infections and wounds. It is approved by the FDA as a food additive or flavoring agent.

Peppermint and menthol also got a bad wrap from Ms. Begoun. The truth is it is also listed as beneficial to the skin. I use it for sunburns (wonderfully cooling and soothing) and hives. I rub it on my temples, down the back of my neck and over my forhead to relieve headaches. My daughter, who often has migraines, uses it in conjunction with rosemary and grapefruit essential oils for almost instant relief. Where does she put it - on her forehead, temples, down the back of her neck and across her shoulders (in other words, her skin). Remember, peppermint and menthols are very strong oils and should be diluted well with a carrier oil or water. Because it is antiseptic, it is also very good in treating certain types of acne. Put a few drops in a bottle of witch hazel and you have a perfect astringent for acne or a soothing tonic for sunburn.

Dr. Oz also talked about using more natural products and mentioned that we should be careful in our choices. I couldn't agree more. Not all companies are producing products that are safe for our use, even though they make many claims that they are. I want to assure you that Itty Bitty Soaps are made using the best products available, produced in clean facilities and are completely safe for use. I take a great deal of pride in the product that goes out the door and what has my name on it. I stand behind each and every bar of soap I make and guarantee its purity. 


6 comments:

  1. Caroline, this is fantastic information that I know you have researched for years and I consider you to be the expert here. I never put full stock in some of the guest spots on TV or things I read from unofficial sources in women's magazines or newspapers.

    But I do put full stock in you because I know you and trust you 100% and I know the depth of study you have done in this area of healthy living. Thank you so much.

    I just noticed that Laura has taken your Itty Bitty Soap Works to international levels over in Italy with her blog endorsement. Check it out!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Just catching up on past episodes on the DVR and ran across Dr. Oz with cosmetics. I had to stop the show and get out the lap top when I heard lavender was bad. Cell Death??? Doesn't that happen naturally I said to myself. Thanks for your posting so I can be at ease that my purchase of organic cosmetics and essential oils is not a waiste of money.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Unfortunately, if you google "Lavender cell death" you will find scientific studies back up Dr. Oz's comment... and yes, lavender essential oils are not only included in this, but are the main issue. I would be interested to know your thoughts after you have fully informed yourself on this issue, as I know Dr. Mercola has put out an organic skincare line that includes lavender as a beneficial ingredient. It is very difficult for the average person to spend the time researching every ingredient out there... *sigh* Especially when most people put their own agenda in the way... If you were to read and find out that lavender is in fact damaging to the skin, would you be brave enough to share this information and to revise the ingredients of your products to reflect that information? I am not meaning to be confrontational, but just wanting to start a conversation on this topic.

    ReplyDelete
  4. By the way... Dr. Oz also recommends lavender on his site. It is very frustrating to try to understand this... but I get the feeling it maybe the amount of lavender essential oil used in a product that becomes a problem, and also how it is manufactured.... It would be so wonderful if someone knowledgeable in this area could do the research on both sides of the argument and share something unbiased and clear to answer on this issue!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I was searching for the episode where this was talked about and have not been able to find it. Do you happen to have a link to the show?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Lavender Oil DOES cause cell death, there are studies that prove it.
    The thing is: essential oils are very strong chemicals. They might help a bunch, but they always have their side effects. That is how they can kill bacteria and be anti-fungal, anti-infectious that effectively; they are strong killers. The thing is, when applied to skin, they may help you with your skin problems by killing the bad intruders, but will also affect your skin, mostly your cells, and many times in a bad way as well. They many times cause cells death, accelerate aging, collagen degradation, etc.

    That is the reason why aromatherapy has always been the art of INHALING (mostly by burning) gums/waxes/herbs/oils to bring a mental state.
    When you turn our modern, harsh essential oils into components of cosmetics, that gets in contact with our skin, we are using aromatherapy in a secondary way. The problem is that we have little research about their effects on skin, even less on cells and collagen, or the internal body, hormones, etc.

    ReplyDelete